• Criticker icon
  • MovieLens icon
  • Taste.io icon
  • Letterboxd icon
  • IMDb icon
  • +6

Movie recommendation tools, by how they actually decide

Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski11 appsUpdated
Copy a direct link to this comment to your clipboard

Every tool here answers the same question — what should I watch tonight? — but they disagree about who gets to decide.

Some predict a score for you specifically, from your own ratings. Some show you a crowd average. Some only tell you where a film is streaming. That difference is not cosmetic: once your taste drifts from the average, a popularity feed and a personalised predictor start recommending completely different films.

Ordered roughly from "models you" to "models everyone" to "does not model taste at all". Several do more than one job; each is placed by the thing it does best. Not a ranking — they are good at different things.

  1. Criticker icon
     Like

    Criticker.com is an independent, self-funded recommendation platform that has been online since 2005, free from third-party influence. Built and maintained by a small team of passionate movie lovers, Criticker helps film, TV and gaming enthusiasts discover titles that truly...

    Cost / License

    • Free
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    Homepage
    Move and TV show recommenadtions
    Move and TV show Collections
    +3
    Trending titles on Criticker
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    One of the very few that predicts a score for you specifically, by weighting the users whose ratings have historically correlated with yours. The idea is stronger than the interface, which is showing its age — but the idea is the right one, and it has been right for twenty years.

  2. MovieLens icon
     Like

    MovieLens helps you find non-commercial, personalized movie recommendations. Rate movies to build a custom taste profile, then MovieLens recommends other movies for you to watch.

    Cost / License

    • Free
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    MovieLens helps you find movies you will like. Rate movies to build a custom taste profile, then MovieLens recommends other movies for you to watch.
    Find movies that are similar to the ones you like. Tune the matching algorithm so that the results are "less violent", "more realistic", or "more ninja".
    Learn more about movies with rich data, images, and trailers. Browse movies by community-applied tags, or apply your own tags. Explore the database with expressive search tools.
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    A GroupLens research project at the University of Minnesota, and the reason a large share of the collaborative-filtering literature exists at all. Rate a few hundred films and the predictions get genuinely good. No streaming integration, no polish — it is a lab, not a product, and it does not pretend otherwise.

  3. Taste.io icon
     Like

    Taste.io is a personalized movie recommendation app. Unlike the major rating sites, this suggestion engine is designed to return personalized matches with no commercial bias.

    Cost / License

    • Freemium
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    Taste.io screenshot 1
    Taste.io screenshot 1
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    Gives you a percentage match per title, computed from your own ratings, for film and TV. Of everything here it is the closest in intent to what I work on, which makes it the fairest comparison and the one I watch most closely.

  4. Track watched films, rate and review titles, create personalized lists, explore trending movies, and join a global community sharing recommendations and discussions.

    Cost / License

    • Freemium
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    • Apple TV
    • Software as a Service (SaaS)
    Letterboxd screenshot 1
    Letterboxd screenshot 1
    Letterboxd screenshot 2
    +5
    Letterboxd screenshot 3
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    The social layer for film: diary, lists, reviews, and the best writing community in the category. Following people whose taste you trust beats a global average — but you have to find them first, and what you get is a model of your friends, not of you.

  5. IMDb icon
     Like

    Launched online in 1990 and a subsidiary of Amazon.com since 1998, IMDb is the world's most popular and authoritative source for movie, TV and celebrity content, designed to help fans explore the world of movies and shows and decide what to watch.

    Cost / License

    • Freemium
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    • Kindle Fire
    • Software as a Service (SaaS)
    IMDb screenshot 1
    IMDb screenshot 1
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    The crowd average at maximum scale, which is both its strength and its ceiling. Unbeatable for settling a fact about a film. But a 7.4 from two million voters still tells you very little about whether you specifically will like it.

  6. Trakt.tv icon
     Like

    Track your TV shows and movies automatically with media integration and mobile check-ins. Discover new favorites and use the extensive API across platforms.

    Cost / License

    • Freemium
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    Trakt.tv screenshot 1
    Trakt.tv screenshot 1
    Trakt.tv screenshot 2
    +5
    Trakt.tv screenshot 3
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    Tracking first — it scrobbles what you watch across players and services, automatically. The viewing history it accumulates is excellent raw material for any recommender; the recommendations Trakt itself builds on top are the weaker half.

  7. Simkl icon
     Like

    Tracks TV, anime, and movies with automatic logging, cross-device sync, watchlists, global streaming info, recommendations, social features, and subscription management.

    Cost / License

    • Freemium
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Chrome OS
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    • Discord
    • Google Chrome
    • Stremio
    • VLC media player
    • Jellyfin
    • Crunchyroll
    • Plex
    • Emby
    • Kodi
    • Netflix
    SIMKL Custom Lists Official Page
    SIMKL Custom Lists Create Page
    SIMKL My Stats Page
    +13
    SIMKL Rewatch Tracking
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    Tracking across film, TV and anime, with the most forgiving import story if you are migrating from somewhere else. Discovery is secondary to the log.

  8. It's completely user driven by people like you. TMDb is currently used by millions of people every month and with our and powerful API, also used by many popular media centers like Moovida, XBMC, Plex, MythTV and MediaPortal.

    Cost / License

    • Free
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    The Movie Database  screenshot 1
    The Movie Database  screenshot 1
    The Movie Database  screenshot 2
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    The open data layer much of this category is built on, including my own project. Thin as a place to browse; indispensable as an API for ratings, credits and localised artwork. Community-maintained, which shows in both the coverage and the occasional gap.

  9. JustWatch icon
     Like

    Find out where to watch movies and tv shows legally online with JustWatch. The streaming search engine.

    Cost / License

    • Freemium
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    • Apple TV
    • Android TV
    Website - Home Page
    JustWatch screenshot 1
    JustWatch screenshot 2
    +4
    JustWatch screenshot 3
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    Answers "where can I stream this" rather than "what should I watch". It solves a real problem well and its country coverage is the best here, but it assumes the decision is already made.

  10. Reelgood icon
     Like

    Reelgood shows you where to find the content you want on the services you need. Just pick out a couple of things-- movies you want to watch, TV shows you're watching-- and Reelgood handles the rest. Streaming made easier, with just a single tap.

    Cost / License

    • Free
    • Proprietary

    Application type

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    • Android Tablet
    • iPad
    • Apple Watch
    • Trakt.tv
    Reelgood screenshot 1
    Reelgood screenshot 2
    Reelgood screenshot 3
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    Same job as JustWatch — availability and watchlists across streaming services — and strongest on the US catalogue. Tells you where, not what.

  11. Likewise icon
     Like

    Get personalized recommendations on the best TV shows, movies, podcasts, books & more from sources you know, trust & admire. Check out Likewise today!

    Cost / License

    • Free
    • Proprietary

    Platforms

    • Online
    • Android
    • iPhone
    Likewise screenshot 1
    Likewise screenshot 2
    Likewise screenshot 3
    Marcin JablonskiMarcin Jablonski’s note

    Recommendations spanning film, TV, books and podcasts, leaning on social signals and an AI assistant. Broad rather than deep — useful if you want one place for everything, less so if you only care about film.

No comments so far, maybe you want to be first?