Mozilla updates Firefox Terms and Privacy Notice, sparking user concerns over data privacy
Feb 28, 2025 at 4:50 PM

Mozilla updates Firefox Terms and Privacy Notice, sparking user concerns over data privacy

Mozilla has updated the Terms of Use and Privacy Notice for Firefox to enhance transparency regarding user privacy commitments. This update has sparked concern among users over a specific clause granting Mozilla a nonexclusive, royalty-free, worldwide license to use information input through Firefox. Users argue this contradicts Mozilla's Principle 4, emphasizing the importance of internet security and privacy.

A Mozilla employee addressed these concerns, explaining that the license is essential for Firefox's basic functionality, such as processing searches, and does not imply data ownership beyond what's described in the Privacy Notice. The new policy formalizes existing practices, allowing Firefox to operate as intended, including storing personal information and accessing files for user navigation. Despite some user confusion, software licenses like this are necessary for software operation, and Firefox's new agreement reflects standard industry practices.

This situation still reveals a recurring issue in how Mozilla communicates with its user base, and how such updates can spark concerns — for a very legitimate reason — really quick.

Feb 28, 2025 by Paul

MaoholguinTBayAreaPat
du
shazmataz
Maoholguin found this interesting

Comments

Kismet
Mar 3, 2025
0

yep, in 128 or 132 version - idk exactly, they introduced some auto-on feature,fuction - whatever... And it just switched me instantly to move on to LibreWolf... They still haven't added to import bookmarks manually - you need to log-in on Android to acc. And just reliance on G-money is pretty expected they will eventually slide on to some shady stuff

Asumeh
Mar 3, 2025
1

The fact that people are now starting to trust Mozilla less and less is concerning. I mean, I understand that the last few years, it hasn't been perceived well with questionable changes; but this must be the final straw for some.

As mentioned in my review, I can only hope the Mozilla foundation can recover from its unfortunate mishaps, earn back the trust of privacy-conscious users like myself, and hopefully not abandon Firefox altogether. However, with the alleged data collection practices (from what I'm seeing), I don't know now if it's worth it to switch from Firefox. If this is all true, then maybe. But to what browser?

  • Firefox forks tend to fall behind the original Firefox's updates, thus making them a tad less secure. Mullvad and Tor I think are a bit too much, since after sessions, I get logged out of websites I'm usually logged in to. (This is a personal nitpick; I just don't feel like taking that extra step.) Not to mention it's a bad idea to change the default settings since you'll stand out in a crowd.
  • Brave, based on what I read, falls behind hardened Firefox in terms of fingerprinting protection and privacy; and uBlock Origin icon uBlock Origin does a better job at blocking trackers, ads, and other malicious content than Brave Shields.

I understand that all this sums up to be "I'm not aiming for 100%/maximum privacy" (not to mention that 100% privacy is impossible unless you just stop using the internet), so of course, I'd like to balance convenience and usability with privacy and security at the same time.

*So... at this point, should I switch from Firefox? Or should I not? Well, I guess for that, I have to wait and see what Privacy Guides icon Privacy Guides thinks...

Navi
Mar 2, 2025
-5

I don't think anything actually changed. This is just a formality in relation to a few features like telemetry if enabled, connecting to Mozilla servers when running updates, bookmark syncing using an account and so on.

1 reply
Navi
Mar 3, 2025

Why all the down votes? I have yet to see anyone look at the code and show something is different. They added a feature they anonymize ad data in order to pressure advertisers to not bother collecting data anymore and you can opt out of this. This is likely what is being referred to on owning the data.

Mr. Anon
Mar 2, 2025
2

I'm sure the temptation to "sell out" is quite appealing, despite the horrific moral implications. I'm admittedly a Brave fanboy due to my preference for Chromium and the Privacytests.org results, and I don't want to be a part of the direction Mozilla is going. As a collective voice, people have to realize that walking away, "voting with our wallets", and voicing our frustration when our rights are infringed upon is how we make our impact. Hell, I loved when Mozilla came out with that car privacy report, but now this?

jethro_tull
Feb 28, 2025
10

When I pointed out the change in the Mozilla Foundation's board of directors vis-a-vis an effective hostile takeover, and the potential negative consequences thereof, I was accused by someone here of "meaningless fearmongering". And now, here we are. Fortunately Librewolf, Mullvad, Floorp are solid forks. They are not updated quite as often, but Librewolf seems to have mainline patches within 3-5 days, in my experience.

1 reply
Leslie Burke
Mar 2, 2025

I just tried Floorp and i didn't like it as a Browser and Librewolf is causing me problems to install But Mullvad browser i think i have tried it before but I might just delete Firefox I was only using it for the online sync I will stick to Brave browser as the best browser.

Álvaro Ayres
Feb 28, 2025
4

This might be the last push I needed to switch to something else. I will start experimenting with alternatives.

Shaz Shah
Feb 28, 2025
3

Yeesh. For a browser company that advocates user privacy and clear ToS, they really didn't think it through. Happy to stick with Zen Browser.

2 replies
Leslie Burke
Mar 2, 2025

I just installed the Appimage version of Zen Browser. I never used it before and it was confusing and weird to me but i'm happy you enjoy it.

Shaz Shah
Mar 3, 2025

No worries, everyone has their own tastes. I like it for the vertical tabs and the ability to have split tabs (side-by-side views), so I find it helpful for research.

Show more comments
7 of 8 comments
Gu