Brazil officially bans X over a legal dispute and imposes fines on users using VPNs

Brazil officially bans X over a legal dispute and imposes fines on users using VPNs

A Brazilian judge has ordered the suspension of X (Twitter) due to Elon Musk's failure to appoint a new legal representative in the country. Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes instructed the National Telecommunications Agency (Anatel) to restrict access to X within 24 hours. Additionally, Apple and Google have five days to remove X from their app stores in Brazil. To make things worse, individuals attempting to access X via VPNs will face daily fines of $50,000 Brazilian real (approximately $8,900 USD).

Elon Musk recently shut down X's offices in Brazil after Justice de Moraes allegedly threatened to arrest the company’s legal representative. Musk has accused de Moraes of undermining free speech and acting with political motives, labeling him an "unelected pseudo-judge." The conflict has been ongoing since April, when de Moraes started investigating X for reactivating accounts that were ordered to be blocked for spreading misinformation, many of which are linked to supporters of former right-wing President Jair Bolsonaro.

X maintains that it is not enforcing U.S. free speech laws in Brazil but is resisting de Moraes’ demands, which it argues violate Brazil’s own laws. The company plans to publish all of de Moraes’ demands and related court documents to contest the judge's orders. For users in Brazil looking to avoid VPN fines, consider popular X alternatives like Threads (by Meta), Bluesky, or the always-recommended Mastodon (where you can also follow us).

by Mauricio B. Holguin

MaoholguinMathemagicianAzazeljethro_tull
Maoholguin found this interesting
X iconX
  1098
  • ...

X, formerly known as Twitter, serves as a digital town square for users worldwide. As a social network, it offers features like hashtags, threaded conversations, and trending topics to facilitate real-time discussions and information sharing. With a rating of 2.4, its top alternatives include Mastodon, Gab, and Diaspora.

Comments

Tiago Sousa
-4

I have my criticisms of the Brazilian Judiciary, but Minister Alexandre de Moraes is right! We cannot allow the financial interests of an United Statian billionaire to affect Brazilian sovereignty. This nonsense about "American Freedom of Expression" used by this unscrupulous billionaire is a subterfuge for the shady interests he has in Brazilian lithium. If he (Musk) does not have a far-right government in place in Brazil, things would be difficult for him to exploit the mineral for his incompetent Tesla car company. This United Statian has to understand that the Brazilian Constitution is not based on the United State First Amendment and that United Statian legislation should ONLY be applied in the United States. Brazilian legislation on freedom is far ahead of United Statian legislation, but the spoiled billionaire does not accept this and wants to force a imperialist interference in another country to satisfy his unbridled greed. Elon Musk needs to be placed under a guardianship to prevent him from taking such deplorable actions. There is a lot of money and a lot of power in the hands of a psychologically unbalanced, drug-using person like him.

3 replies
Leslie Burke

what the hell is United Statian? you seem to be speaking nonsense. you know it's the United states.

Leslie Burke

spoiled billionaire How is Elon musk Spoiled? Are you angry because you are not rich yourself? imperialist interference in another country How is Elon musk an imperialist to brazil?

imperialism /ɪmˈpɪərɪəlɪz(ə)m/ noun noun: imperialism a policy of extending a country's power and influence through colonization, use of military force, or other means.

Leslie Burke

You say all sorts of crazy things about Elon Musk like Elon Musk needs to be placed under a guardianship to prevent him from taking such deplorable actions. There is a lot of money and a lot of power in the hands of a psychologically unbalanced, drug-using person like him.

But How do you know Elon Musk is a drug-using person? and He's a Grown adult Are you discriminating against him using Drugs? He's not a Minor He's a grown man. and you seem crazy to be so hustle and offensive to him and I don't like Elon musk but what you said has nothing to do with Brazil.

Codex Crypto
4

I have my criticisms of Elon Musk, but in this fight he's right. Brazil's supreme court, the STF, has turned the country into a veritable dictatorship of the judiciary led by the tyrannical minister Alexandre de Moraes, who disregards the laws of the Brazilian constitution itself and intimidates even other ministers who dare to contradict his tyrannical decisions. To give you an idea, he has already blocked Telegram for a period of time and, through illegal orders, censored hundreds of groups and channels. Not long ago Rumble had to leave the country to avoid complying with illegal orders, but now the target is X. Unfortunately, many people are being persecuted and imprisoned, including politicians and journalists, just for having an opinion contrary to the current government. The situation has reached the point of total absurdity where Minister Alexandre de Moraes has ordered a fine of around 8,911.54 dollars for anyone using a VPN, as well as ordering the withdrawal of all VPN apps from stores. This prompted Proton VPN to issue a statement to Brazilians protesting against the dictatorial censorship of the supreme court of the Brazilian judiciary. Brazil is not far removed from George Orwell's 1984.

3 replies
k 4u

Thanks for the insights mate! Sometimes it is very practical to have the questions one is being bugged about in a post by someone, with few but really relevant details. I was wondering - what happens if you're a tourist and use a VPN, though? Quite curious about this one...

Leslie Burke

If I were in Brazil I would use Tails OS or Whonix to access Twitter and do what I please. you don't have to like Elon Musk I don't either but thank you for being honest about Brazil and staying on topic. I didn't even know about the dictatorial censorship of the supreme court of the Brazilian judiciary. This is why I am not going to Russia or china Even Brazil I wouldn't even go to Mexico since the Mexican cartel and nowhere is safe even Going to Iran is dangerous But Japan south Korea European countries and the Philippines are safe countries.

Codex Crypto

Thank you for your attention and the world needs to know what is happening in the dictatorship in Brazil. I don't like Elon Musk either, especially projects like Neuralink and others that make me very suspicious of him. If you're not a Brazilian citizen, I imagine you won't have a problem... The decision by the dictator of the Brazilian judiciary in the STF, Minister Alexandre de Moraes, was so absurd that after much negative repercussion he was forced to backtrack on the ban on VPNs in stores, but the exorbitant fine remains for those who use X with VPN. Even some newspapers in the mainstream Brazilian media are already criticizing the minister for disrespecting the laws of the Brazilian constitution and not following the rules of due process. Chris Pavlovski chose to leave Brazil with Rumble so as not to comply with this supreme court justice's illegal censorship orders and even Telegram has been targeted by him in the past. The only good thing about all this is that many people are discovering how good it is to use VPNs and decentralized social networks like Nostr and Mastodon. Journalists Glenn Greenwald, Michael Shellenberger and others have criticized the dictatorship of the Brazilian judiciary in a series of international reports on the subject.

“Lawyer Adriano Soares da Costa said that, through a monocratic decision, Moraes established a legal instrument similar to a Provisional Measure, “which conveys a general and abstract norm for all Brazilians, replacing the National Congress and the STF Collegiate, without a process or a rite. An act of absolute and supreme power by a STF minister,” he said. According to the jurist, the decision, which has general and abstract effects, as if it were a law, affects those who are not being investigated, those who will never be summoned by it, in other words, “it is an unprecedented legal aberration”. In addition to assessing that this is “a usurpation of the competence of the National Congress”, the decision constitutes an “unimaginable innovation in the legal system, with no support in the Constitution”. The jurist equates Moraes' act to an institutional act of the military regime because it is based solely on the will of the minister and the power of his office.

Alexander Coelho, a partner at Godke Advogados and a specialist in Digital Law and Data Protection, believes that, from a technical and legal point of view, Moraes' decision raises significant questions. According to Coelho, the Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet requires that the blocking of social media accounts takes place on the basis of a specific court order and after due legal process, guaranteeing the rights of defense.

In this sense, Adriano Soares da Costa notes that the suspension of social media profiles is “an extreme measure that requires compliance with the Constitution and the Civil Rights Framework for the Internet”. He points out that the Civil Rights Framework for the Internet establishes the need for due process of law to be applied, the initial indication of links with illegal posts, the right to an adversarial hearing and a full defense for those whose accounts and publications are to be suspended or blocked. It would be virtually impossible to do this for all Brazilian X users with current technology.”

Azazel
-5

How they intend to detect a user is accessing xwitter via a VPN? Unless it's a state-run VPN I have some doubts the plan will work 😂

Anyway I see the Brazilians winning here, since their mental health will greatly improve by them being off the MAGA, rashist and racist troll-swarming cesspool.

3 replies
bird

I'll be honest, social media as a whole is in a rather sad state. I heard someone claiming that Instagram does a better job at not amplifying political content, but I am sceptical, and Instagram's a Meta company.

UserPower

Brazilian authorities have asked the dozen of companies offering VPN in Brazil to log users access to Twitter/X (just as they are required for illegal content), but it seems authorities have already went back on it because there would be too much false positive (and so, a great amount of paperwork). Sure, it must be empowering to think you're above the law when you're the head of a hundreds millions users social network, but and the reality kicks in and you loose about 25 millions users in few days (about 10% of total users), I'm not sure there will be a worse time to beg advertisers to go back. Let's say this story just adds up to the endless Twitter drama.

Navi

If the traffic uses the type of gateway and encryption VPNs use it is easy to detect.

Mathemagician
3

Nice and neutral display of the current state. It's easy to fall into bashing one side or the other here. I'm glad you avoid that.

bird
1

Fining someone for using a VPN is a bad idea: at the same time, Elon Musk is playing with matches in his attempt to push his version of free speech, while trying to sue people that don't agree with his actions or call out Twitter/X for inflaming violence.

1 reply
Leslie Burke

I use Mullvad VPN and i pay in Bitcoin.

Gu