Alternatives to TheBrain for all platforms with any license

Platforms

Desktop

Show 17 less popular platforms

TheBrain Comments

Very Expensive $219/Desktop Version, $299/Cloud Version

Comment by bopperjr346
about TheBrain · May 2015 ·

Looks like a great program but at $200+, it seems overpriced for the consumer market.

Reply

Terrible pricing

about TheBrain · ·

Totally agree about the pricing scheme. Completely unreasonable for anyone not using it professionally, and even then it seems unreasonable!

Reply

Good Program, mean pricing

Comment by JoeCamel
about TheBrain and yEd Graph Editor, CmapTools · Oct 2012 ·

What is the main drawback of a mind-mapping program? Try to make a circular connection, it's something always some kind of workaround and not on the same level with the standard connections. Mind maps are essentially tree-shapes. concept-maps don't have this restriction.
i don't know how they programmed it, but cross-references are more or less "created equal". This and the automatic layout makes it a good program to use for things that are interdependent.
the bad thing about this program is the pricing scheme. the free version leaves you without printing and exporting which makes the free version a complete trial or vendor-lock-in version.
the pro version is too expensive for a person not using it to earn money with it , so it is to expensive for a student arranging the thesis or a person just entering their knowledge and saving it in a flexible, interconnected way. a lawyer, detective, advertising guy or any other person connecting various informations may find it reasonable to pay more than $200 for a program that has a narrow scope but fills that purpose better than others.
as an alternative (true concept-mapping and not the hierarchical mind-mapping) to "the Brain" i suggest cmaptools,
yed graph editor is neither mindmapping nor conceptmapping tool, but it can be tweaked into such.

Thank you...enjoyed your comments. I love the graphical representation of relationships...and agree on the criticisms.

Hey, I know I am late to the party, but I just stumbled upon your comment regarding yEd. I think you are either confusing yEd with another program or somehow misinterpreted the information about yEd, because your comments about pricing are just plain wrong: At the time of writing there is no "paid"/"pro" version and there never has been. Also the "free" version (which is the only version available) is not restricted in that way at all: you can print and export and I do not see how this can be a vendor-lock-in, because even if you decide to not use yEd anymore the files that you have created are stored at your side and they are plain XML files that you could import into third party tools anytime. Thanks!

@yGuy. You're obviously not very good at paying any sort of attention. The reviewer was OBVIOUSLY & clearly talking about TheBrain. Not the software you're talking about. TheBrain is the software with an unreasonable pricing scheme. Whatever made you think they were talking about something else?! It's a review, about TheBrain, on a page FOR TheBrain. facepalm

Oh and furthermore, he was recommending it as an alternative. Not bashing it.

@SpaceOctopus: The confusion is probably because this review is on the "related comments" section of the yEd app page, while all the others are comments about yEd.

Reply

I haven't bought this software because:1. You can't manuall ...

Comment by TimAustralia
about TheBrain · Jun 2011 ·

I haven't bought this software because:

1. You can't manually order nodes.
Considering the main aim of the product is to tame masses of information, this is a major downfall.
It's also despite the fact that this feature is the third most requested one as of writing. (I think this was also a problem 10 years ago when i first tried it)

2. People have lost data on it (something about a java upgrade) - which would be disastrous for the only use I would ever consider paying for

3. It's very expensive - starting at $150, for features that are fairly necessary for any serious use. Given point 2, the price is hard to justify. Given point 1, I can't use it any price.

4. Other commenters are right that it is a bit hard to get a grip of all your info at once.

Having said all that, it's one of the most intriguing pieces of software I've ever seen!
Such a shame about the other points.

Reply

That's true, it's not really a mind map. But I don't think ...

Comment by Michal
about TheBrain · Jun 2011 ·

That's true, it's not really a mind map. But I don't think it's a drawback. Thanks to the possibility to have any item "thought" as your central thought, you can focus on it and see everything directly connected with it. If you need to see the big picture, there are possibilities like outline view and expanded view (the first being very good to see hierarchy in the system, the other is a kind of mind map, where you can change the position of each individual thought).

The problem with the mouse oriented interface was solved with the release 5.5, where you can set your own keyboard accelerators to almost any command.

There are some thing I don't like on PersonalBrain (for example you can't make links directly from item notes to another item, or I miss the possibility to make a nice list of items arranged according to some attributes) but whenever I tried to find something that would fit me better I landed back on PersonalBrain after a while.

And BTW with the nice dynamic interface it will be a lot of fun to organise your stuff and go through it.

Give it a try! (there is a free version without some features, but very useful anyway.

Reply

This is true, but remember that if any item becomes the cen ...

Comment by dyslucksia
about TheBrain · Jun 2011 ·

This is true, but remember that if any item becomes the central topic, this can result in limiting the scope of items viewed to those immediately related to the item - quite a limiting factor IMO. Using PB is a bit like shining a torch around a room in the dark - it only shows a small fraction of what's there. Mind mappers show large, detailed maps whose items don't jump around the way they do in PersonalBrain's display, which can be disorienting. Because the displayed spatial relationship of items changes completely with each new central item ("Thought") the user may find it difficult to create a mental "map" of his database. Hence PersonalBrain should not be confused with mind maps.

PersonalBrain as an application shows a lot of potential, but IMO this has a long way to go before it is comfortable to use, even though it has been around for 10 years. Its interface is highly mouse-oriented, so can be very inefficient at times, particularly to keyboard users. The manual omits a lot of important details, making it a difficult application to learn to use well, and once you get to know it you start discovering many gaps in its features which have not been implemented despite being requested by many users for years.

It can handle relatively large information databases but is held back by inadequate capability to manage such databases.

Reply