4.6 out of 5 with 16 ratings

Manjaro Linux Reviews

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 7 Helpful Report as spam

AUR probably has the biggest selection of newest software today. The classic distro to use if you want to have access to this, is of course, Arch. But Arch is a pain to setup. Not so much to install - if you follow the install guide to the letter you can get Arch working pretty easily. The problem is what happens after. The guide will walk you through getting a basic GUI set up, for instance, but you might have all sorts of weird issues like flicker or mismatched fonts that will have you going down Google rabbit holes for days. A lot of things, like video drivers, break a lot and are hopelessly complex, troubleshooting that stuff is no fun at all. And at some point, you get sick of the mandatory crash course in obscure configuration, implementation details and bugs of every piece of software you have, and just want to have a working system and work on your own work, and not the system.

Manjaro lets you do that. The installer is helpful, and will actually set up an Arch system with a few bells and whistles at the level a reasonably advanced Arch user would. It doesn't do a perfect job, and there's probably Arch users out there that could install Arch better manually than the Manjaro installer. But as a novice user, as I said you can follow the wiki and get a working system. But if you want to customize it to your needs, the learning curve will be very steep and you will probably have to live with a system that is broken in a bunch of small ways for months or even years. With Manjaro you don't have to - it will certainly do a better job than a newbie following the wiki for the first time, no reading required. One could argue that a person uninterested in reading the Arch wiki shouldn't use Arch-based distros. Well... The other distros kind of suck, and the newbie distros (Mint, Ubuntu) are bloated messes. Manjaro is a pretty good compromise between not being a bloated mess and working out of the box. Your Manjaro install will probably have some problem or other (welcome to Linux, lol), and they might be problems you wouldn't have had in Arch. But in Arch you would have other problems (the ones that Manjaro solves), unless you know Linux quite well. If you knew Linux quite well, you wouldn't be reading a review about Manjaro to decide if you should use it, so I'll assume you don't, in which case, I absolutely recommend trying Manjaro! Maybe give Arch a shot first just to understand what the real deal is supposed to be like, play with it for a few days, get frustrated trying to fix everything. Then wipe that and install Manjaro - you'll get an instant feeling of relief.

There are two downsides with Manjaro and they have to do with the community and its origins in Arch. Manjaro is basically Arch with a fancy installer, some themes, a handful of additional packages (like a utility to switch kernels easily and a pacman GUI). There's very little difference and 99% of what you read on Arch wiki will apply, except that you'd only need to read it 10% as often because usually Manjaro just works to begin with. A few things will not apply, for example the kernels used by Manjaro are I think slightly different. Despite this, anytime you seek help all the Arch people will tell you to get lost because "Manjaro is not Arch". It is hard to objectively describe to someone who hasn't experienced it, but the Arch community is a bit abrasive to begin with, and they have a bizarre enmity to Manjaro users. Obviously if you were very knowledgeable, you would use Arch, not Manjaro, so all the experts are Arch users - but even though Manjaro is currently #2 on distrowatch vs. Arch on #16, Arch users constantly try to marginalize and exclude Manjaro users from any online help community. So something you will learn quickly is to lie about using Manjaro when asking for help. As I said, 99% of the time it won't matter, and the 1% you just have to learn (it's really not such an unpredictable thing as the anti-Manjaro Arch users will make it sound).

The other issue with Manjaro is that Arch is a rolling release OS. You get the latest version of every software, and the Arch position is that you're supposed to update everything on your system, even AUR packages (and you will have a lot of AUR packages because the repo has fuck all) every day, sometimes multiple times a day. This can take a lot of time and is a pain in the ass. A sensible person would recognize that, probably not much changed between puppyfartsoundboard v1.32.7.8cf and v1.32.7.8cg and there's no need to keep it on the bleeding edge - in fact, you only really want the security updates for a handful of critical systems. For everything else, the vast majority of updates will add little or no values for the user. Yet Arch requires you to spend time doing it over and over. You can't even update only important software because in Arch, partial upgrades are not supported. You can do them no problem - I have for years and it's fine, nothing breaks. In fact it will break less because occasionally Arch updates themselves will break. The Russian roulette at every update is part of The Arch Way, and every time you run pacman -Syu you basically have no idea if it will be fine or if you'll spend an hour figuring out how to even get your DE back up. So you are actually better off updating as little as possible, but if you do and something does break, good luck getting help. Without fail, a bunch of Arch users will show up (even though Manjaro Is Not Arch) and lecture you on how partial upgrades are bad, and then leave without solving your problem.

On the topic of packages, nice as AUR is it actually has a major security flaw. It's not a flaw of the system per se. But AUR packages are installed by running scripts which can do very bad things to your system. This was obviously first set up for Arch and the expectation from an Arch user is to read and audit every script. Sometimes these scripts will download and run other scripts. Most will be written in bash (yuk!). You will typically get 50-1000 lines. They will not be the tidiest code ever. So here's what will happen in practice: Unless you know bash very well, it will take an hour or more to read all that code, not to mention looking up syntax you don't know or actually verifying if it does what you think it does for less obvious lines. You will not do this every time you need to install something from AUR. You will train yourself to blindly trust hundreds of scripts from strangers on the internet. If these scripts have malware, oops! So you can take this in two ways: Either installing every AUR package (don't forget dependencies!) takes hours because you need to closely check the install script, or it is horrendously unsafe because you're not just blindly accepting everything. I would guess 90% of Arch users are the latter, but, pick your poison.

So if you can put up with these proiblems, Manjaro is actually a great system. There is an additional flaw in that it uses systemd, but there are precious few realistic alternatives that don't. Other than these, it basically has no issues. Probably one of the best daily driver desktop distros (hell, OSes) available right now.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 5 Helpful Report as spam

I'm enjoying using Manjaro for that reasons:
Easy to install almost ready to rock
Stable and works great on my machine
Arch user repository access
Cutting edge software and rolling releases

I wanna thank Arch linux and Manjaro contributors for everything from base to wiki and forums.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 3 Helpful Report as spam

Absolutely beautiful OS. pacman is fine, getting used to using sync instead of install is a matter of familiarizing myself with the terminology I suppose. I'm finally ditching Windows as my host OS and I'm deciding which distro I want to go with. Manjaro is definitely a contender.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 2 Helpful Report as spam

Modern website. Easy to follow tutorials. Large community.
Great choice if you have been using only Windows OS before.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 1 Helpful Report as spam

Its architech edition is one of the best if you want to select all packages one by one for your needs but fully customized distro from almost stratch but based on Arch of course.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 1 Helpful Report as spam

Manjaro rocks. Perfect for developers with recent compiler/libraries.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful 2 Helpful Report as spam

Wonderful KDE implementation.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

Just install and use it. For Gnome DE users I suggest some extensions like Dash to Panel, Removable Drive Menu and Disconnect wifi.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

It is an easy to install and easy to use Arch Linux derivative. It has various Desktop Environments available and the Arch repository available (you have to activate manually). The Manjaro Settings allows to choose drivers (both opensource and proprietary drivers) for all your piece of hardware. There is also a great community support via Forum.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

Manjaro is the perfect choice between most Linux distros and Arch linux. Ever since I tried it out, I've been daily driving it and haven't regretted it once. It's quite stable yet allows a lot of customization and has support for the AUR.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

Easy to use whilst also exploiting the great advances of Arch and Arch's massive variety of programs (official repos & AUR). Several DEs available (XFCE, KDE, Cinnamon, etc).

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

Manjaro has the flexibility of Arch Linux, but is much easier to get started. The installer is very easy to use. Manjaro includes access to the Arch User Repository, which lets you download and install just about any piece of Linux software available.

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

Really grand Linux distro n good for starters

reply

about Manjaro Linux · · Helpful Not helpful Report as spam

Its based on Arch and it gets super unstble when doing large floating calculations, like simulating qubits. You might find this not helpfull, but im telling that for those who would find this interesting...

reply