Microsoft OneDrive Reviews

WorkAround: OneDrive for Vista-Administrators (UAC off)

about Microsoft OneDrive · ·

It is crazy, that OneDrive cannot be run with Administrator-Accounts on Windows Vista, if the UAC is disabled and the registry has the standard parameter-set.

Details to this disappointing fact see:

  1. Why wont SkyDrive run with Administrator Accounts on Windows Vista?
  2. German: Bei der Installation von SkyDrive unter Windows Vista erscheint eine Fehlermeldung

    • Why on earth can't skydrive run with Administrator access enabled? Everything else NEEDS administrator access!
    • Bei der Installation von SkyDrive unter Windows Vista erscheint die Fehlermeldung: "OneDrive kann nicht mit vollständigen Administratorrechten ausgeführt werden. Starten Sie OneDrive ohne Administratorrechte neu."

Error message, when starting OneDrive with UAC disabled

Workaround-SOLUTION against the OneDrive-Vista-UAC-Bug:

  • Initially the UAC must be activated !
  • Go to regedit (Windows-Start-Button -> Regedit)
  • HKLM/Software/Microsoft/windows/currentversion/policies/system and disable (put it to 0): ConsentPromptBehaviorAdmin (normally 1)

Now you are able to use OneDrive as an Vista-Administrator with disabled UAC.

Additional information about the behaviour of the value ConsentPromptBehaviorAdmin

[Edited by em4020, May 29]

What's crazy is still using Vista!

Reply

SkyDrive vs. Dropbox on Windows 7 and 8

about Microsoft OneDrive and Dropbox · ·

I recently recorded my syncing sessions to demonstrate the latest SkyDrive and Dropbox clients. The Windows 7 video was done at work within a Wi-Fi corporate network (behind proxy); the Windows 8 video was done at home within a typical Wi-Fi home network (no proxy). Both the SkyDrive and Dropbox folders were identical and up-to-date (idle) before I copied the GIMP folder into each. Instead of taking this at face value, I suggest you do your own comparison because YMMV. Here are the videos:

Note that the videos strictly compare syncing performance. To decide for yourself you will also have to take into account the features that are unique to each client: mainly LAN sync for Dropbox and online document editing, remote PC access, and more free storage for SkyDrive.

BOTTOM LINE: Dropbox is A LOT faster, although it's a memory hog and uses a little more CPU time on average. SkyDrive seems to just casually upload a few files at a time and ends up taking forever, even with the performance option enabled.

After performing these comparison tests, I have come to the following conclusion: SkyDrive isn't meant to be as fast as Dropbox -- it's slow by design. I think Microsoft built SkyDrive to sit back and kind of "trickle sync" with the goal of minimizing CPU and memory usage. If this was indeed their goal, then they succeeded because with SkyDrive running you'll hardly notice it's working in the background, whereas sometimes Dropbox drives up the CPU to the point where you hear the fan start to spin up.

More information about the test setup is provided in the description for each video.

Thank you for doing the comparison, I had already mostly decided to dismiss Skydrive as an option due to the free + paid storage offerings(will be needing 500+gb before the new year), and after seeing the speeds I'm quite sure now. Dropbox always was swift, but their space/price ratios are also just too far behind what others are offering for the extra speed to offset in most cases. Although compared to gooDrive and evidently M$ Skydive(based upon your vids), the case is indeed a sports car vs buggy race. Also, with equal speeds, it seems that Google's recent free storage bump, and paid price cut, puts Skydrive in the severely outmatched category for the moment.

Dropbox servers basically only act as proxies/buffers until the content can be offloaded to an Amazon S3 server, this gives them the mentioned speed, but I can't see them ever being remotely competitive on the $/GB front so long as they are renting the space. DB is thus great for fast sharing of files, storing frequently updated current projects, or as an email proxy for +10mb files, but without frequent file shuffles, or a high priced plan, it becomes an overstuffed pain very soon. While Google Drive falls on the opposite end of the spectrum, with 15gb free & 100gb currently $5/mo, it can be used to keep a fair amount of old projects synced across multiple computers as long as there is no rush.

Another option, unless you need DB/Skydrive/gDrive for conformity/work reasons, is you might try the same test between DropBox and Copy and see what you think. I don't have any vids, but their sync app pretty much maxed out my line on both down sync at 2.5mB/s and up sync at 120kB/s with two 50mb zip files. While I do use Gimp portable, I was unable to reproduce your test for myself as Copy uses file hash matches as a method to speed/bypass uploads, so the gimp folder upload took less than two minutes from the time I hit paste till it was synced and available online(tried again with 1gb of apps selected, but only 144mb of that had to upload, they are just too common of files). DB did spike quickly to +100kB/s and stay there, but there is simply no way to compete with matching a hash to a server cached copy to complete an upload.

Thanks to you, Skydrive will not even be considered, so while I'll always have gDrive(using Gmail) and I'm still double checking all my options, it does seems that Copy is my top current top pick. It seems a viable replacement for Dropbox's speed, and the $/Gb of their paid accounts currently beats even Google(except no $5 plan). And for a few months at least, I can get by on their free storage option since if you sign up from a referral link (https://copy.com?r=VjyqiP ) you get 20gb free & with a tweet about copy you another 2gb of free & a referral of your own gaining you 5gb more(I don't tweet so I have 25 now). If you give them a test run, I'd be interested to see one of your comparison vids posted; please and thank you.

Reply

It works. It provides a lot for free. Can't believe it's a MS service. :)

about Microsoft OneDrive and Google Drive, Dropbox · ·

For a project, I recently compared what service brings you the most free space between Dropbox, Google Drive and SkyDrive.

Ease of use was also a criterion.

Results : I've been a long time user of Dropbox, and I love the way it just works without clutter. But in its basic free form, you get only 2 Gb. Google Drive : Gb, and at bit messy imho, with its weird interactions with Google Docs and the rest of the Google nebula. Microsoft Skydrive : 7Gb for free ! Moreover, a nice automatic inteface for uploaded photos, easy way to share.

(I used to hate Microsoft and love Google. But for some years, Google seems to be the one that makes cluttered, buggy and fenced apps. This is another example.)

Reply
about Microsoft OneDrive · ·

Windows Live SkyDrive works well with Windows and is a great file upload service. You can't really edit much which is annoying but okay, whatever. It has a pretty good amount of space. It should have more universal compatibility because (quite honestly) it is a big advertisement to Windows. So... all in all this is good but until they can provide universal compatibility so I can sync to my Ubuntu to my Windows 7, it's not perfect.

Overall : 4 1/2 out of 5 stars.

Reply

interweb batch uploading sanity MIA

about Microsoft OneDrive and Amazon Drive · ·

EVERY third party application to (batch) upload to skydrive is an abomination of code/design.

The interweb interface to SkyDrive is so 1995 it hurts

Reply